Main

January 23, 2008

January updates

Here's your close-to-the-end-of-the-month round up of student loan stories that caught our eyes in January:

-Along with all the news about the mortgage loan crisis, we're starting to hear rumblings of the same regarding student loans, from American Public Media.

-Candidates talking about loan issues? Well, a little. From NASFAA.

-Tax advice from Kiplinger.

-Loan forgiveness for firefighters is proposed, as well as for lawyers in Florida and Illinois.

-A year ahead preview on student loan issues from Inside Higher Ed.

-An OpEd on the legacy of debt, and another piece on debt in general (and one on student loan worries).

-More on those free money offers borrowers get in the mail.

Student Loan Debt Clock = $472 billion.

January 3, 2008

A Caucus Race

"What I was going to say," said the Dodo in an offended tone, "was, that the best thing to get us dry would be a Caucus-race."

"What is a Caucus-race?" said Alice; not that she wanted much to know, but the Dodo had paused as if it thought that somebody ought to speak, and no one else seemed inclined to say anything.

"Why," said the Dodo, "the best way to explain it is to do it."

-Alice in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll

Today it starts, the true kickoff to the 2008 presidential campaign: the Iowa Caucus. (For news and information regarding the Iowa Caucus, check out the Des Moines Register caucus section, Iowa Caucus 2008, and IowaCaucus.com. And for an overview on caucuses in general, check out this Wikipedia entry.)

To gauge the impact of the Iowa Caucus, check out this breakdown of past results from the Des Moines Register, which shows that a win tonight and a strong second place finish bodes well for those who end up in front. Now is the time to ask the candidates who come through your part of the country what they plan to do in terms of student loans. Do they care about those of us who are struggling to pay our loans under the yoke of usurious interest rates, or do they only care about future students? Are they for the citizen borrowers, or the corporate lenders? What are their stances on the reauthorization of the Higher Education Act, and will that reauthorization provide students and borrowers with much-needed relief?

Remember this quote from Sam Seaborn on the West Wing:

I worked in a State Assembly race in Manhattan in a district where Democrats outnumbered Republicans 16 to 1. But everywhere we went, there'd be one lone poster of a right-wing nutbar who wanted to to eliminate the income tax. And he was holding up signs and canvassing everywhere and bugging the local reporters until we had to comment on it. So I introduced myself to his campaign manager, and I said, "What are you doing? Your candidate doesn't have a chance and neither do your issues." He said, "This is what I believe. And no candidate gets to run in my district without speaking to my issue."

Make the candidates speak to your issue any way you can this year.

Student Loan Debt Clock: $ 470 billion.

November 20, 2007

Well you know, November has come...

...and the holiday season is suddenly upon us. There are always plenty of stories about debt at this time of year, and this year is no exception:

-A Cornell student writes on the culture of debt.

-American Medical News writes on the student debt of physicians, as does CNN, while the Ledger Independent notes that public defenders have much student debt as well.

-NorthJersey.com has an article on graduates buried by debt, as does the News Advance.

-In Illinois, the Quincy Herald-Whig reports that "Gov. Rod Blagojevich announced last week $1.22 million in grant funding for Illinois Veterans Home nurses who are paying off student loans."

-GenDebt Commenter Joe has started a website called Advice On Time to provide free advice on all sorts of issues, including some debt issues.

-Meanwhile, Congress is still working on reining in student loan lenders' deceptive marketing practices.

Student Loan Debt Clock is at $465 billion.

Have lovely Thanksgiving from GenerationDebt.

October 30, 2007

No October Surprise here

When October rolls around, my thoughts run to electoral politics, whether it's actually an election year, or, like this year, just feels like one (the presidential election is still well over a year away, I'm getting tired already). So check out some stories on the student loan positions of those jostling for the presidency in 2008 from The Chronicle of Higher Education (also here and here) and The Times and Democrat.

-More stories on Congessional student loan reform from The Seattle Times, The Chicago Sun-Times, The Coumbia Spectator, The New Paltz Oracle, The Sheboygan Press (this one is against government student loans), The Washington Post (letter to the editor), and The Toledo Blade.

-Stories on the student loan debt burden from The Contra Costa Times, The Columbia Tribune, CBS News, Daily Press, Business Week, The Buffalo News, The Daily Bruin, The Pepperdine Graphic, and The Winston-Salem Journal.

-In other news, D.C. has a program to help medical workers pay student loans in exchange for service in low income parts of the District, Scott Burns wonders if going to college pays, and Kiplinger discusses whether student loans affect a mortgage application.

Student Loan Debt Clock is at $462 billion - looks like we're back to a growth spurt.

September 20, 2007

A little autumn debt reading

And away we go...

-Articles on recent student loan legislation from: AEI for Public Policy Research, The Village Voice, Reuters (also here), The New York Times, The San Francisco Gate, The Baltimore Sun, The Washington Post, PBS, USA Today and The Star-Telegram.

-Articles on student/graduate debt from: The Chicago Tribune, BusinessWire, NJ Voices, Time, The New Yorker, The UNLV Rebel Yell and The West Virginia Record.

-Alan Collinge thinks that the recent student loan legislation didn't go far enough. And here's an article from Anya Kamenetz on debt issues in the upcoming presidential election. USA Today advises consolidation "only if it's right for you".

-Finally, just for fun (er, sure, fun), check out this inflation calculator. Calculating what someone who graduated college in, say, the 70s or 80s paid in terms of today's dollars can be eye-opening.

Student Loan Debt Clock: $458 billion - is the new loan legislation helping to lower the clock?

August 9, 2007

The dog days of debt

1 darling debt.jpg

As the days of August swelter on, there's still plenty of student loan news to report. While many in the media are focused on those students just starting out on their debt journey, there are still some that remember the borrowers who are already stuck in it for the long haul. And so we trudge on...

-Not content with sticking it to college students, our friends at Sallie Mae now offer loans for parents for K-12 private schools. Just like the tobacco industry, the student loan lending industry likes to hook 'em young.

-Alan Collinge of Student Loan Justice writes about Sallie Mae's march toward monopolizing the student loan industry.

-More on the student loan scandals from ABC News, the Brandenton Herald, CBS News, Inside Higher Ed, The Daily, and the Washington Post.

-New legislation and potential legislation in Congress may help some or hurt some, reports Inside Higher Ed (also here), the New America Foundation, CQ, the Chicago Sun-Times (also here), the Washington Post letters page, MTV, the Earth Times, US News, NPR, AM New York, News and Tribune, the Post Crescent, the Cleveland Plain Dealer, the St. Petersburg Times, the Christian Science Monitor, and the Springfield News Leader.

-The stories on student debt in general are still coming out, too, such as these in The Nation, the San Francisco Gate, the Chicago Sun-Times, the Omaha World-Herald, and the Fort Worth Star-Telegram.

-One group, the Business and Media Institute, claims that the media are picking on the poor lenders in their news portrayals, mentioning the demonization of lenders and a victimization theme when it comes to borrowers.

Student Loan Debt Clock: $487 billion and ticking away more every second.

Pic via Pandagon.

June 6, 2007

Notes on a scandal

The main story in student loan news these days is growing coverage of the student loan payola-style scandal. It basically breaks down into this: Lenders and schools have/had deals whereby schools would push students to a certain lender or lenders in exchange for kickbacks from the lenders.

For those of you wondering if this scandal has or had any impact on those of us with consolidation loans we're now stuck with, the answer is a resounding yes. I remember heading to the financial aid office as a first year law student, asking about financial aid, and being given paperwork from two lenders. I remember not being specifically advised that I could or should shop around (yes, I was naive, and yes, many students are, making them a ripe target for this sort of thing). I remember going with one of the two proffered lenders. I remember having to then consolidate with that lender when I consolidated in 2001, as the single lender rule was still in place then. And now I'm locked in a loveless marriage with a lender that takes my high interest payments and hands them over to a CEO who uses them to fuel a private jet to fly Congressmen to vacation spots. Yes, I can see a connection between this scandal and the way things are now.

More on the scandal from The Tomah Journal, Campus Progress, US News, Medill Reports, OnPoint Radio, Guardian UK, The Times-Gazette, Salon, Reuters, and Reuters again (Senate hearing on student loans is today, by the way).

It's also interesting to note that the Department of Education has now changed its rules regarding federal student loan programs, requiring "universities to include at least three lenders on any list recommended to students and that would ban many of the incentives loan companies have been offering colleges and university officials to win student business."

In more general loan news, here's an opinion on debt burden from the Asbury Park Press, a piece on candidate stances on student loans from the Yorktown Patriot and one from Inside Higher Ed, an article on Obama's loan stance from Reuters, a story on debt from the Patriot Ledger, a story on debt from Gloucester County Times, a column about previous consolidation from CNN, a story on rising debt from the Portland Press Herald/Maine Sunday Telegram, commentary on another way to pay back loans, a plea for loan relief from someone writing in to the LA Times, an analysis of Sallie Mae using racial politics from CNN, and a feature on being young and in debt from USA Today.

Finally, for all of you out there who have thought of filing an antitrust lawsuit against your lender, the Supreme Court just made it harder. "By a 7-2 vote in Bell Atlantic v. Twombly, the Court said 'a bare assertion of conspiracy will not suffice' to get beyond the summary judgment stage in claims under §1 of the Sherman Act." Which essentially means that plaintiffs will have to have proof of conspiracy in the pleading stage, not an easy thing to get early on in a case against a big corporation.

Student Loan Debt Clock: $477 billion - growing faster than a duck pouncing on a Junebug.

May 9, 2007

The merry month of May

Hello all. Student loan news is heating up even as the weather does this spring, and we have a ton to report:

The New York Times discusses the plight of debt-ridden culinary school grads, and a whole lot of folks get in on the discussion in the blog/comment section. More on the lifelong debt burden of student loans comes from The Daily Southtown, Sys-Con Media, Buzzflash, The Arizona Republic, the ABA, the Temecula Valley News, the Chicago Sun Times, and the National Law Journal.

Kiplinger has a note on loan forgiveness for teachers.

Dealbreaker mentions the sale price of Sallie Mae, and The Independent reports the sale. Note also Saliie Mae's contributions to U.S. Representative Howard "Buck" McKeon.

Meanwhile, the New York Times reports that "JPMorgan Chase & Company invited more than 200 officials in town for the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators’ meeting two years ago on a July 4 dinner cruise up the East River", an event that cost over $70,000. That would never happen today, according to JPMorgan Chase, because of the increased attention being focused on the cozy relationship between lenders and schools. Yes, that's right, we've got ourselves a genuine student loan scandal, and just look at all the coverage it's getting:

-The New York investigation: Scripps, WNYC, the Indy Star, Inside Higher Ed, and Time.

-The Congressional investigation: ABC News, Inside Higher Ed, and the Concord Monitor.

-The fallout and commentary regardng both: The Washington Post reports that Theresa S. Shaw (a former sallie Mae excutive, natch), chief operating officer of the Office of Federal Student Aid, is stepping down in the wake of the widening investigations of student loan issues. Education Department official Matteo Fontana was found to hold $100,000 worth of stock in a student loan lender. Ellen Frishberg, student financial services director for Johns Hopkins University, has resigned her membership on "an Education Department committee that helps develop financial aid regulations." Columbia City Paper offers some extreme solutions. The Washington Times comments on both investigations and the industry in general. A Yahoo News opinion column calls for a revamp of the system. An economist's view is noted at the Bangor Daily News.

Student Loan Debt Clock: $473 billion and growing all the time.

April 2, 2007

April - the cruelest month for loan news?

We slide into early spring with news about pending bills in Congress, debt loads in general, and even some (sort of) juicy investigations (as juicy as investigationsregarding student loans can be, at any rate).

-Congress has been hard at work targeting the student loan industry for reform, but will it help those of us who've been out of school for awhile and are dealing with usurious interest rates? The College Student Relief Act looks like it helps undergrads only. Or how about the Married Student Debt Relief Act? It "would double the student loan interest tax deduction to $5,000 for married couples who file a joint tax return when both spouses hold student debt." (No help for me, there, I'm afraid, since I'm single and "make too much money" to deduct student loan interest on my taxes - a "fact" which makes April quite cruel, to me.) Folks in Iowa might be getting some student loan help soon, though, with the introduction of a bill that would give employers a tax break for helping employees with student loans.

-A helpful reminder from the Scripps Debt Advisor: student loans are loans you can only get rid of by paying them or dying. No discharge in bankruptcy, and no real help if you're disabled. For more on how debt sticks with the borrower for a looooong time, check out articles from Red and Black, the Daily Texan, the Cornell Sun, the Shield, the Chicago Tribune, and the Toledo Blade. Bob Herbert has weighed in on student debt recently, as well. Note also that Georgetown Law recently held a roundtable discussion on student debt, and you can check out a webcast of that discussion. And here's a little advice on trying to get lower interest rates for private loans.

-You might have heard that New York is investigating banks and universities for getting too cozy over student loans. You might also have heard that the cases settled. So much for a nice, loud soapbox on the industry.

-Poor Sallie Mae, the embattled underdog (that'd be sarcasm) of the student loan world. Al Lord must be crying into his $18.3 billion stock sale profit over his troubles. More on the student loan lobby (and Sallie Mae) here and here.

-Here's a random opinion column link that we thought you might want to weigh in on from the Yorktown Patriot: "higher education gives little return to society for the enormous resources it sops up." Thoughts?

-For your reading pleasure: Make Love, Not Debt, the blog of a couple trying to work out their debt issues.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $467 billion - when it rains, it pours.

March 2, 2007

In like a lion

Ah yes, that's how March comes in, roaring with student loan news:

-There are quite a few stories about Generation Debt lately, bemoaning the fact that students are stuck in debt for life, but not particularly calling for any specific action or relief: Carolina News 14 ("with some students in for the long haul, financial experts say we may see a generation that is perpetually in debt"), the Globe Gazette ("[t]hirty-four percent of those graduating from college with debt have sold possessions to make ends meet, according to a recent survey conducted by AllianceBernstein Investments, Inc. Forty-two percent of those surveyed said they live paycheck to paycheck, and 27 percent reported they delayed getting a medical or dental procedure done because of their debt"), the Kansas City Star ("it’s time for older generations to realize that things are different. School costs are rising quicker than salaries can keep up. Social Security will be dried up when we need it. Pensions will be read about in history books. The retirement age is creeping toward never"), WFIR 23 News, and the Harvard Crimson ("What concerns us is that not enough of you, at Harvard and elsewhere, will spend your twenties and thirties doing the vibrant and vital work required of every rising generation to advance civilization—be it teaching, producing great works of art, challenging injustice, or defending our nation—simply because these jobs do not pay enough").

-Congress has started moving on legislation to "require banks and other lenders to compete for the right to make federally guaranteed student loans, with the goal of identifying those who could offer the loans at rates that would cost the government the least, and using the savings for other efforts to make college more affordable for students." More here, here, and here. Inside Higher Ed brings up the problem (at least from our point of view) with the legislation: "the House-passed legislation provides no help for the millions of borrowers who are currently having trouble repaying their loans because of high debt levels and/or low incomes. It would have been much better if the House had sought to help these borrowers, for example, by allowing them to consolidate all their federal student loans into a single loan repayment schedule when they leave school and begin repayment. This expansion of existing consolidation provisions would greatly simplify the student loan system by allowing borrowers to refinance their student loans once they leave school." Some people don't want to help graduates, though, or students.

-Possible student loan relief for Kentucky public interest lawyers and Arizona teachers. But the Roanoke Times advises against using home equity to pay of college debt.

-Some folks are suspicious of the relationships between schools and lenders, according to the Business Week.

-Alan Collinge of Student Loan Justice editorializes on student loan abuses, mostly by Sallie Mae, and Today's TMJ 4 investigates predatory student lenders, including Sallie Mae. Check out more interesting Sallie Mae news here, here, here, and here (after reading some of that, I think Al Lord might want to have a chat with Martha Stewart about his stock practices).

-The United Graduate Debt Program offers some different solutions to the problem of student debt.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $462 billion - just keeps springing forward.

February 2, 2007

February news

Now that the first 100 hours of the new Congress has passed (quite a few more hours than that, in fact), there's more news than ever regarding student loan issues, if not particularly our issue. Let's get to it:

-Inside Higher Ed writes (and writes and writes) about the new student loan bill pending in Congress that will cut interest rates (for current students, mind, not graduates), but will the Bush administration oppose it? More on the bill here, here, and here.

-More on the debt problems of graduates from The Denver Post, American Public Media, CNN, and Tuscon Weekly.

-The Student Loan Justice Political Action Committee and a TPM blog from Student Loan Justice.

-Prosecutors and public defenders in South Carolina may get help with their loans.

-And finally, some voices from the other side of the debate, arguing that education shouldn't be subsidized by the government at all, and that a Republican has a more progressive student loan plan than the Democrats.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $458 billion - feel the love, eh?

January 5, 2007

New year, new Congress, new student loan policy?

The 110th Congress got going yesterday, making history by providing the nation with its first female Speaker of the House, San Francisco, California Representative Nancy Pelosi. The House got started by voting in new ethics rules yesterday, and in upcoming weeks plans to tackle issues such as increasing the minimum wage, implementing the 9/11 commission’s recommendations, easing restrictions on federal funding for stem cell research, authorizing negotiations for lower drug prices under Medicare, cutting interest rates for student loans, and repealing tax breaks for the oil industry. The Senate, led by Nevada Senator Harry Reid, is to deal with immigration reform, expanded stem cell research, and Iraq policy.

There have been quite a few stories in the last few months on the plans of the Democratic majority to lower student loan interest rates, including these in the Lawrence Journal-World, the Mercury News, the San Francisco Gate, and the Ledger.

But not so many articles have discussed refinancing and reconsolidation of student loans, which would ease the financial burden of high interest rates on borrowers who have already graduated. A blog entry on TPM Cafe exhorts the new members of the House and Senate Education Committees to "decline campaign and PAC contributions from Student Loan interests during your term on the Education Committee" in the interest of promoting the welfare of student borrowers as opposed to that of lenders.

Now is the time to renew efforts to apprise our representatives of our problem. Write letters (I have updated sample letters in our Resources section), make phone calls, and write to the media. With all the buzz about the new Congress and its interest in student loan issues, let's make sure our issue doesn't get lost in the shuffle.

Tangentially, check out this article from Kiplinger's on Sallie Mae's profits, an article about couples registering for student loan payments instead of china as wedding gifts, and an article advising that buying a home is not the best step to take to get out of student loan debt.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $453 billion - happy new year!

December 7, 2006

Snow misers

Along with snow and holiday things, December brings us more student loan news.

-The Buffalo News notes that lenders are wary of the shift in power in Washington: "Within the student loan industry, the impending transfer of party control is producing waves of anxiety - in part because Democrats have promised that one of their first acts will be to cut interest rates on student loans." More stories on changes in student loan policy along with the change in Congress can be found in the Concord Monitor, CNN, Inside Higher Ed, and the Washington Post. TPM Cafe even calls for an investigation of the Department of Education regarding student loans. Note also that rumor has it that California Representative George Miller will be the new head of the House Committee on Education and the Workforce, with former Chair John Boehner tapped to be Minority Leader.

-The Chicago Sun Times discusses the loan difficulties of young public interest lawyers, noting that "while their salary is a fraction of their private-sector peers, their law school debt may be equally crushing. And that has created a situation in which the offices of prosecutors and public defenders are finding it increasingly hard to hire and retain lawyers." More on student debt consequences: the Orlando Sentinel and USA Today.

-The University of Maryland Baltimore County opines that student loans are barriers to higher education.

-Kiplinger offers general advice on getting out of debt faster. More general student loan advice can be found in this USA Today article, as well as this Newsday article and this Roanoke Times article.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $449 billion and growing all the time.

Happy holidays to all from GenerationDebt.

November 2, 2006

November spawned a student loan news monster

Sorry folks, I just can't help but commandeer that Morrissey song title when I post in November. Lots of links to pass on, so let's get to it.

-The Washington Times has commentary on student loans, including the cash cow they are for Sallie Mae. On a similar tangent, note that one private loan company is holding an all expenses paid meeting for financial aid administrators at the Four Seasons Resort on a Caribbean island.

-USA Today notes median debt levels of graduating students have increased in recent years.

-The Checkout blog at The Washington Post discusses student loans, and asks the key questions: "Are you better off for having taken on student loan debt? Or is the cost of higher ed and the terms and conditions of student loans creating a new type of indentured servitude?"

-The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette discusses graduate student loans, noting that a "financial aid administrators' 2003 survey said that among those who left school in that year, average repayments ranged from 7.4 percent of starting salary for some master's recipients to 16.3 percent for some law graduates." The Post-Gazette further notes that student loan burdens can affect job, family and housing choices.

-A Letter to the Editor in the Fredericksburg Free Lance-Star laments the gain of student loan lenders at the expense of student borrowers.

-The Independent Florida Alligator notes that no one's talking about student debt in this election season.

-One group is lobbying for changes in the Department of Education's loan program, including "limiting student loan payments to 15 percent of any income above 150 percent of the poverty level after graduation ... instead of the standard set rate repayment option, which ignores varying salaries."

This postcard from Post Secret hit home for me, so I thought I'd share:

student loans.jpg

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $443 billion and ticking higher.

October 20, 2006

Debt for life - now that is scary!

The back-to-school slew of student loan articles has tapered off over the last few weeks, but I do have a couple of pertinent notes/links as we head into the end of October:

-Stanford is planning to forgive student loans for those students who teach. "The loan-forgiveness program applies to graduates of the Stanford Teacher Education Program, a yearlong master's program for K-12 teachers at the university's School of Education. Under the program, STEP graduates will have half of their student loans forgiven after they teach for two years; the remainder will be forgiven after they complete four years of teaching."

-Out in Oklahoma, a similar idea is percolating, with buzz regarding "creating legislation to reduce a student’s college debt if he or she practices [as a veterinarian] in a rural area for a certain length of time."

-Meanwhile, some students and graduates who don't happen to be teachers from Stanford or rural Oklahoma veterinarians recently testified at a hearing at the U.S. Education Department that they (we, I should say) are "drowning in debt" and it's affecting many aspects of their lives: "Some students say they will have to forgo lower-paying careers in favor of jobs that guarantee big bucks to pay off their loans. Others say they are picking graduate schools based on where they'll get the best deal, not necessarily where they'd get the best training."

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $441.7 billion and growing all the time - that is a truly chilling fact for this Halloween season.

September 29, 2006

End-of-September links

Here's a round up of links I've been skimming recently:

-Another article on Anya Kamenetz's Generation Debt book.

-An article on how debt sends grads home to live with the parents, and one on long-term student debt in general.

-One on how student debt burdens futures, including causing some students to drop out or forego college altogether.

-Another Michelle Singletary column on student debt (you can read it here, too), where she notes, "The rising student loan levels are so troubling, it's time we stop saying this is good debt. 'Having over $100,000 in student loan debt is not fun,' wrote one reader, a new lawyer who joined me during a recent online discussion. 'Do I regret going? No, but it certainly didn't pan out the way I thought it would. I am working like a fiend, not getting paid what most people think lawyers make, and struggling daily with money and budgeting. There are hundreds, from my class alone, who are in the same boat.'"

-An article on the rise of private student loans, noting, "In the past five years, tuition at public colleges has increased 57 percent, but the maximum amount students can borrow from the federal loan program hasn't risen a dime — it's stayed at $23,000."

-Finally, some possible good news: information on loan forgiveness for certain professions.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $438.5 billion.

September 1, 2006

Welcome to September

Fall is arriving (my own personal favorite time of year), and there are even more articles about lingering student debt out there:

-The Detroit Metro Times reports on Generation Debt:"As more and more young people get in too deep, students, parents, educators and lawmakers are proposing solutions. The seeds of a grassroots activist movement against debt are being sown. But is it too little, too late?"

-Meredith McGhan at Nevada Today checks out books on student debt (namechecking us in the process), and exhorts people to get up and do something: "But no excuses — time crunch or no, young people need to become much more proactive for social change, even if it’s just to join an online group and send a ready-made email to one’s representative or senator."

-A Denver CBS affiliate reports on the crush of student loan debt:"Some graduates will be discouraged from going into education and public-service fields because their salaries won't be high enough to offset their loan payments. Some will still be paying off their debt when they should be saving for their children's education. Others won't be able to afford to buy a house or car. There are several factors driving the student-debt dilemma. But simply put, experts say the cost of higher education has continued to climb and financial aid isn't keeping pace."

-More on mounting student debt from the Durango Herald Online, the Youth Policy Action Center, and the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

-On the potential solution side of things, Alternet offers a solution of debt relief for national service, and looks at other reasons and solutions. The Commission on the Future of Higher Education recently dropped language from a report which would have recommended tha families look to private loans for money for students.

National Student Loan Debt Clock: $434 billion.

August 8, 2006

Back to school time...

Ah, the late-summer days of August. Time for barbeques, going to the beach, getting in last-minute time off, and, of course, a slew of articles about student loan debt just in time for back-to-school.

-The Boca Raton News reports on student loan debt being a "major worry of recent grads.".

-Alternet has an article on "The Real Tragedy of Student Debt", looking at one woman's personal story, one that discusses the arguments of many that students without money for college should not go to prestigious schools or should not go at all: "To be fair, I made the choices that put me in this situation. I attended an expensive university 3,000 miles from home. I stayed at that school, even though I could get a cheaper education elsewhere. I studied an impractical subject that I loved, then continued my studies at an obscure foreign university. I wasn't always aware of financial consequences.

Yet I made my choices based on the values I had been taught -- that helping others is more important than making money for yourself, meaningful career is more important than net worth, and brains, determination, and charisma are the key ingredients of success. I realize now that I subscribed to the fantasy of an equal society, when in fact everyone's options arise from class, race, gender, and a thousand other subtle differences in our experiences, assumptions, and privileges."

-The Indianapolis Star asks if high school grads are being priced out of the college market.

Student Loan Debt Clock: has topped $430 billion.

July 19, 2006

A few links on debt for degrees

-More on the long-term consequences of student loan debt from the Herald of Bradenton, Florida and The Daily Aztec.

-This Cavalier Daily column calls student loans a racket and a scam.

-A Bloomberg opinion column on how college costs damage the futures of Americans, and it offers some solutions, as well.

-Campus Progress asks: What is the purpose of higher education in American society? "If part of the answer is to create opportunity and ensure that America remains a nation where anyone can build a better life for themselves, then we need public policy reflective of this goal."

Student Loan Debt Clock: over $427 billion and counting...

July 5, 2006

Hot enough for ya?

A few things to think about in the realm of higher education and student loan news as you enjoy your summer:

-High student loan debt is steering doctors away from general medicine and towards more lucrative specialized practices.

-Another Michelle Singletary column referencing the ban on refinancing previously consolidated loans: " 'My daughter has some student loans as a result of going to law school,' one father wrote. 'She has told me that she cannot consolidate her loans at this time as she has already done this once. This sounds unusual as people refinance a number of loans more than once. Is it true that students are only allowed to consolidate one time?'

Sorry dad, your daughter is right.

If you've already consolidated your loans, you can't do it again unless you have a new federal student loan or a loan that was not included in the original consolidation. And don't write me about it. Write to Congress to complain about this ridiculous rule."

-The U.S. Department of Education has "declined to implement a recommendation by student groups and lenders to simplify its regulations on student loans and make them more fair."

-More on the high cost of higher education, and the consequences of student loan debt from San Francisco's Beyond Chron: "These debt-burdened graduates are forced to forgo internships, fellowships, alternative career opportunities and the general adventures of young adulthood because of ever-increasing debt and rising interest rates.
***
The bottom line, however, is that an alarming number of students cannot afford higher education—and are therefore either not going to college, leaving the country or struggling well into their thirties just to pay off their diploma, before they can even start their career. As ... [college] officials ... consider raising tuition prices for the betterment of their particular schools, they would do well to realize that the real issue in American higher education is not the renovation of buildings or throwing up a new recreation center. Rather, the real concern is that the high cost of higher education is on the verge of making a diploma in this so-called nation of dreams a nightmare to achieve—yet another blow to the hammer driving a wedge between America’s haves and have-nots."

-From progressive website Toward Freedom, a discussion regarding class privilege in higher education: "In the United States, access to a college education is still a privilege not available to everyone. As the tuition rates continue to climb through the roof and competition for financial aid increases, more and more people are shut out of this system."

*Student Debt Clock is over $425 billion.

June 16, 2006

No big deal, eh? We think not.

This morning on Good Morning America, resident financial guru Mellody Hobson did a spot on student loan consolidation. While the linked article on the GMA website mentions the one-time cosolidation rule in passing, Ms. Hobson mentioned it a bit more in her spot this morning, stating that it was a drawback that wasn't really a drawback, since it's so unlikely that rates will go down once a borrower consolidates. As we know, however, thousands of borrowers beg to differ.

More articles have come out regarding the effects of student loans on the lives of borrowers long after graduation, including one from The Arizona Republic, one in The Columbus Dispatch, one in the Times-Tribune of Scranton, PA, and one in USA Today.

There's some good news for first-time consolidators, however, in the form of the repeal of the single holder rule. This allows borrowers to shop around for the best deal on consolidation, instead of requiring them to consolidate with their original lender. A step in the right direction, to be sure.

In other legislative news, Senator Clinton has introduced S. 3255, The Student Loan Bill of Rights Act of 2006, which is another step in the right direction, but still seemingly doesn't address the issue of allowing refinancing of previously consolidated loans. One lender has decided to take matters into its own hands on this issue, and has filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against the Department of Education and Secretary Margaret Spellings: "The lawsuit requests a temporary injunction against a ruling that eliminated some consolidation options on March 31, three months before the July 1 deadline. The suit also challenges the constitutionally of the Higher Education Act, the congressional bill that brought about these changes, because the House and the Senate did not pass identical forms of the bill."

*National Student Debt Clock is up to over $422 billion.

June 2, 2006

How's that monkey on your back doing?

As graduation time approaches (or, er, is already here), articles about student loans are popping up all over. Aside from the usual advice-laden paragraphs advising college grads to consolidate now so they can lock in interest rates before July 1, and advising high school grads to be careful about borrowing for college, there are a couple of more interesting things out there to read:

-This article in the Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal, in addition to advising college-bound folks to avoid borrowing, also shines a little light on the for-profit monster that is Sallie Mae ("now a private corporation whose profits put Exxon to shame"): "The loans have been helpful to millions. They've also become a nightmare to tens of thousands. ... It's not unheard of for a student who has borrowed $25,000 to be facing double that much in arrearages - even after making sporadic payments for four or five years."

-The Christian Science Monitor reports on the "albatross" of student loans: "With hefty repayments in their future, however, many students...are walking away from low-paying government, nonprofit, and teaching jobs. ... Accumulating loan debt even pushes back many of life's milestones, according to a survey that Baum conducted in 2002 for Nellie Mae, a major student lender, which is now a subsidiary of Sallie Mae. The report found that 38 percent of graduates held off buying their first house because of student loans, 14 percent put off marriage, and 21 percent delayed having children.

'We are the first society in history to take our brightest and start them out in debt,' says Allan Carlson, president of the socially conservative Howard Center in Rockford, Ill. 'That's just stupid public policy. We should encourage them to grow, not hold them back.'"

-The Mercury News reports on a recent survey which shows that "[a]lmost seven out of ten respondents are paying off student loans or have spouses who are, and the average outstanding balance is greater than $29,000. Almost 40 percent of graduates with college debt expect to take more than 10 years to pay off their loans."

-Maybe some folks in Washington are paying attention, though, as is evidenced by this Letter to students from Senator Edward M. Kennedy: "Current law, for example, does not allow borrowers to "reconsolidate" - i.e., refinance - a consolidated student loan, but it should. Borrowers who consolidated their loans at higher interest rates in the past deserve to be able to refinance their loans again when interest rates go down, just as homeowners take advantage of lower rates by refinancing their mortgages. I'm also working to reduce interest rates for all student loan borrowers. Lenders are making record profits under the government's college loan program, and restricting student loan benefits is an unfair way to reduce the federal budget deficit."

*National Student Loan Debt Clock is at almost $420 billion and counting...

May 16, 2006

Double recovery

A Greensboro News-Record opinion column laments the state of student lending in the U.S., referencing a report from 60 Minutes which asks whether Sallie Mae's success comes at too steep a cost to students and taxpayers. The report noted that most of the loans from Sallie Mae are government guaranteed, and also reported that Sallie Mae owns some of the largest collection companies in the country. "Once a student borrower goes into default, the government pays Sallie Mae all the principle and compounded interest that have accrued. The loan then passes into the collection phase. If Sallie Mae is the collector, it gets to keep up to 25 percent of whatever is recovered. In 2005, nearly a fifth of its revenue came from its collection business."

As Harvard bankruptcy law professor Elizabeth Warren states, "We have to decide collectively as a country: do we want to encourage the young people who are trying to get college diplomas? And if the answer to that is yes, the way to encourage them is not to double and triple the amount that they owe when they get into financial troubles. ... It's a market in which the protection goes to the lender, [a]nd the students get served up like turkeys at the Thanksgiving dinner."

Such staggering debt prevents some people from working in Federal jobs, as well.

Education Finance Partners, a private loan company, is offering private consolidation loans. I'm not sure how they work, or what the criteria are, but such loans might work for some people.

And one last little note: Student Debt Alert's student debt clock shows the national student loan debt is up to well over $417 billion (up $2 billion since the last time I updated on May 2, 14 days ago).

May 2, 2006

Life Sentence/Reverse Dowry

More articles on the long-term effects of student loan debt, from the State Hornet and CNN Money, which has coined an interesting phrase to describe the problem: "Call it a reverse dowry: college debt diverts careers and delays or impedes graduates' plans to get married, buy a home or even to start a family. The effects can last years."

Central Michigan Life reports on a new online forum on college affordability hosted by the Democrats on the House Committee on Education and the Workforce. Head on over there and make your voice heard.

On a slightly positive note, EMaxHealth reports that student loan debt does not go on one's credit report.

And finally, for a look at the larger picture of student loan debt in this country, check out Student Debt Alert, which has a national student loan debt clock that was showing a national student loan debt of well over $415 billion at the time of this writing, and is rising steadily.

April 13, 2006

Good news and old news

Possible good news for physical therapists: a bill has been introduced "to make physical therapists who are practicing in areas where there are shortages of health professionals eligible for student loan repayment assistance under the National Health Service Corps Loan Repayment Program."

Also, for those in school now, the College Access and Opportunity Act was passed recently, which purports to eliminate the single holder rule (allowing students to shop around for the best interest rate when they consolidate) and increase Pell grants.

On the flip side, check out this opinion column by Congressman Marty Meehan, lamenting the fact that many who want to attend college are financially unable to do so, or rack up crippling debt by attending.

And finally, this Fort Wayne article notes something I've personally witnessed in my profession, namely that "[c]ollege debt is pricing increasing numbers of graduates out of teaching, social work and other modestly paying public-service careers." I think a lot of people want to have service careers, but can't afford to with the student loan burden they carry.

April 3, 2006

Debt consequences, free market competition, and Sallie Mae's connections

Happy Spring, all! (For those of you in places where Spring has arrived, that is, unlike where I am.) It's April, so that means tax time (time again to cringe at the amount of student loan interest you paid in the past year, and if you're like me, time again to be annoyed that Congress deems your salary to be "too high" to be able to deduct that interest). It's also time to pass on the links I've built up recently, so away we go...

-More stories on the long term consequences of student debt from CBS, the Lansing State Journal and the Mercury News. Some parents are willing to give up quite a bit so their children can avoid taking out student loans.

-An editorial asks why isn't the GOP favoring free market competition in the student loan arena? A letter to the editor asks the same question.

-And finally, more on Sallie Mae's political clout, and in particular, Sallie Mae Chairman Al Lord's connections.

March 9, 2006

Lifetime debt

The Chicago Tribune recently ran a story on lifetime debt as a result of student loans: "The impact of big debt from education loans manifests itself in ways that cannot be easily measured. Career plans are altered. Lifestyles are restricted or changed. Home purchases are put on hold. Family plans are often delayed to allow for debt payments." Predictably, at least one letter to the editor regarding this article sings the "it's the students' own fault" refrain, highlighting a lack of understanding of the problem. I don't think most students and graduates are saying we are entitled to a free education, or we want taxpayers to foot the bill. I think most of us are saying that we just wish dealing with student loans was a bit easier in terms of interest and repayment, that we should be able to refinance to get better interest rates, and that lenders shouldn't be making profits and living in luxury off of our backs.

There are also more articles out on Anya Kamenetz's book from The Kentucky Kernel and the Diamondback Online.

Finally, the nonprofit Project on Student Debt is studying student loans and their implications on families, the economy and society. Check it out.

March 1, 2006

Law changes help lenders, not students

First and foremost, let's get this out of the way: If you're here looking for a site about either recently published book titled Generation Debt, this isn't it, though we have posted about those books. Try here for Anya Kamenetz's book, or here for Carmen Wong Ulrich's book.

Onto the news...

-The American Chronicle examines the Single Holder Rule, reconsolidation, and recent changes to student loan laws.

-Sign On San Diego also looks into recent education law changes, and how those changes benefit lenders, not students or graduates.

-The Chicago Sun Times gives Congress an "F" for the recent changes to student loan laws, asking the eternal question, "If you can refinance your mortgage to take advantage of lower rates, why not your student loan?"

-The Free Market News also covers these student loan changes, asking the above question another way, "Can you imagine the uproar if homeowners were suddenly told that they could no longer refinance their home loans?"

-And finally, USA Today examines the consequences of such a large debt burden: "The weight of debt is forcing many to put off saving for retirement, getting married, buying homes and putting aside money for their own children's educations," as well as keeping them from starting businesses and securing any other type of loan.

February 6, 2006

Links of interest

Here are a few links I've come across in recent days that may be of interest:

January 24, 2006

Student loans = debtor's prison?

Nancy Fay of the Temecula Valley News asks, Are student loans a ticket to debtor's prison? Visions of a Dickens-era fate aside, it does seem more and more like this country punishes students for borrowing money to go to college and have a better life.

"Check the Web: More and more students are getting angrier and angrier about their student loans.

They don’t mind paying them back. They just don’t like it when people change the rules in the middle of the game.

'Congress enacted new rules that continue the so-called "Single Holder Rule," which says that once you take your student loans out from one lender, you cannot change that lender,' said Alan Collinge, founder of Student Loan Justice. 'And if you want to refinance to take advantage of historically low interest rates, you can only do that once, if at all. And you can no longer do it while in school. Imagine the outcry if America’s largest mortgage lenders tried to stifle competition by restricting the way we refinance our home loans.'

Yet America’s largest student loan banker did exactly that, and justified it by saying that competition for student loans would hurt its student loan portfolio."


Note also that when President Bush was recently questioned by a student at Kansas University about student loan cuts, he didn't seem to be familiar with her concerns:
"During a question-and-answer session with students at Kansas State University, sophomore Tiffany Cooper asked, 'Recently, $12.7 billion was cut from education, and I was just wondering, you know, how is that supposed to help our futures?'

'The education budget was cut?' Bush responded. 'Say it again. What was cut? At the federal level?'

She repeated the question and clarified that she was referring to student loans.

'Actually,' Bush finally said, 'I think what we did was reform the student-loan program.

'We're not cutting money out of it. In other words, people aren't going to be cut off the program. We're just making sure it works better.'

Becky Timmons, director of government relations for the American Council on Education, said the president had it half-right. 'When you take [$12.7 billion] out of the program, you can both hit the lenders and make students and parents pay a lot more when they repay their loans,' she said."


I believe that both of the above articles are referring to S 1932, Sec. 8009, which, after a (very) quick skim, seems to strengthen consolidation rules, including the single lender rule.

January 20, 2006

"The worth of a book is to be measured by what you can carry away from it."*

A few books (some I've mentioned in the past) have been released on the topic of debt among younger Americans these days:

  1. Generation Debt: Why Now Is A Terrible Time To Be Young by Anya Kamenetz, contributor to the Village Voice. Here's the book site: GenDebt the book.

  2. Gener@tion Debt:Take Control of Your Money--A How-to Guide by Carmen Wong Ulrich, former Money magazine editor. Here's the book site: GenDebt. (We're namechecked on page 18.)

  3. Strapped: Why America's 20- and 30-Somethings Can't Get Ahead by Tamara Drout of Demos.

I haven't had a chance to check them out yet, but I plan to do so soon.

*-James Bryce

January 17, 2006

Link roundup

So far none of our bills have been reintroduced under new bill numbers for 2006, but I'm keeping an eye on Thomas billfinder so I can check them out as soon as possible.

December 15, 2005

Ohio Congressman Boehner's "Tricks" Are Not For Kids

Writer Daniel Auld brought this story to our attention in a comment:

Ohio Congressman Boehner's "Tricks" Are Not For Kids
By Daniel Auld

When Ohio Congressman John Boehner recently told a gathering of student loan bankers that he had some "tricks up my sleeve to protect you," he wasn't talking about new tricks.

He was talking about the oldest trick in the book: "Protecting" business people from competition and innovation. Stopping consumers from getting lower rates and better terms for their student loans.

These tricks are not for kids.

The student loan business is now one of the most profitable in America, says Fortune Magazine. And it did not get that way because student loan bankers are smarter, better or less expensive than bankers in other industries.

It is more profitable because they have more protection from competition. And now Boehner, head of the House Committee that oversees student loan legislation, is promising them even more protection from the one force that drives down prices, improves service, and stimulates innovation: Competition, of course. Which in the student loan business in almost non-existent.

Thank you, Congressman Boehner.

That is the way it was until earlier this year, when in January, the Department of Education ruled that borrowers looking to reconsolidate their student loans could sidestep the longstanding anti-competitive rule against doing so.

It was cumbersome, but effective. Borrowers had to use a two-step process of reconsolidating into the federal governement's Direct Loan Program, then reconsolidating again with a private lender offering better rates. Before then, borrowers were locked in to their current lender no matter what other lenders offered them a better deal.

In May, the Department of Education set aside another longstanding anti-consumer policy by ruling that borrowers who are still in school could convert their variable rate student loans into fixed-rate consolidaton loans before rates increased in July. That way they could take advantage of historically low interest rates, much as millions of other borrowers do with their home loans.

While borrowers celebrated, consumer bankers plotted.

Enter Boehner. Buried deep in legislation to raise prices on student loans are provisions that will largely outlaw the reforms that introduced so much competition into student loans earlier this year.

If passed, student loans would once again be the only thing sold in America that cannot be freely refinanced.

Columnist Dick Morris calls the anti-refinancing scheme an "obnoxious .. ripoff." Terry Savage, the financial columnist of TheStreet.com, says there is "no way" borrowers should support this plan." The New York Times calls it "Robbing Joe College to Pay Sallie Mae," the country's largest student loan provider. The Times Union of New York, calls plans to outlaw refinancing a "student loan shame.'

Boehner's tricks are not for kids.


Thanks Daniel, please let us know where this was published.

December 13, 2005

When it rains, it pours

So much to cover, and so little time lately! Let's dive right in:

  • The GSU Signal writes about student loan issues, and the article, in addition to mentioning the obvious idea that the "kind of anti-competitive practice" allowed in the student loan industry "would not be allowed in most business situations," also references the Wire article in which my own situation is mentioned.

  • More than one book (and I've not yet read any of them) is out or coming out soon about the debt burden of post-college age Americans, including Strapped:Why America's 20- and 30-Somethings Can't Get Ahead by Tamara Draut, and Generation Debt: Why Now is a Terrible Time to be Young by Anya Kamenetz (Anya, an oft-linked Village Voice columnist here on GenerationDebt, also has a blog, and is the author of Robbing Joe College to Pay Sallie Mae, a recent New York Times Op-Ed column.)

  • Former Clinton adviser Dick Morris weighs in on the student loan issue at the New Albany Tribune and Jeffersonville Evening News, stating, "Many students are locked into rates that approach 9 or 10 percent, reminders of the grim economic days of the early 1980s, and find themselves with no flexibility. Frequently, students use their once-only refinancing option shortly after graduation and find themselves helpless as the market interest rates drop ever lower. ... Student loans are the shackles that most young people take into the rest of their lives after leaving school. Keeping this debt hangover large and rendering it inflexible is about as anti- family a policy as you can get, forcing young people to postpone starting families because of the load of debt with which they begin life burdened."

  • Many articles have come out recently analyzing the Congressional drive to cut student loans, in light of the large debt burden that many graduates carry for years after they are out of college, including articles at Alternet, the South Florida Sun-Sentinal, and Bloomberg.

  • And finally, the recent Lockhart decision of